Race is Where the Line is Crossed with Black Panther

Marvel’s latest blockbuster movie, Black Panther, has smashed box office records and is widely considered one of the greatest Marvel movies over the last ten years. After seeing it I do understand the hype as it has a great story line, looks stunning visually, and has a great ensemble of performances from Chadwick Boseman (Black Panther) to the show stealing Michael B. Jordan (Killmonger). And obviously I’m not alone in this opinion as it has grossed 700 million globally in 60 countries.

Outside of the critical acclaim it has also gained a lot of attention from a political standpoint. From ABC, Huffington Post, to Good Morning America and beyond the picture has garnered recognition as revolutionary film for African Americans as the first black superhero movie and giving black children in America the gift of seeing a superhero they can be.

These stances, despite being widely believed and advertised, are simply not true and completely inappropriate and foundationally wrong. This movie is the not the first black superhero film because of movies like Blade (1998) with Wesley Snipes. Others argue it proves black superheroes work in Hollywood, but that was proven twenty years ago. Blade was also clearly successful as evident by the making of two sequels.

My biggest problem with this situation is the idea that Black Panther suddenly gives black children “permission” to be superheros or an example of a superhero they can be. There have been viral posts on social media about “this is how white people feel all the time” describing how black people feel in reaction to seeing a dominantly black cast in Black Panther or funding campaigns to get black children to see this movie so they can see their unlimited possibilities.

No white person goes to a movie theater and thinks to themselves about how Captain America is a white superhero and that is why they love the movie. They go to see the movie because they like action, explosions, and superheroes not the idea of a white lead. That’s how the characters were portrayed in the comic books, it is not because big movie studios don’t think a black superhero will do as well as a white superhero in the box office. They do not pick to make movies about the white heroes they go with the characters who were more prominent and popular in the comic books.

Anybody being any superhero is not a new idea, the idea that a hero like Superman is not relatable to people who are not white is preposterous. You see black athletes like Cam Newton, Dwight Howard, and Shaquille O’Neal donning that Superman logo, doing Superman celebrations, or calling themselves Superman nicknames with pride because they like the qualities of that particular hero.

You may not feel as relatable to a particular hero because of his personality, powers, or even his outfit, but I argue race simply does not play a role in that equation. People who are Asian, South American, or any race still relate to superheroes who do not necessarily look like them, because that is simply not meant to be noticed.

If a black child doesn’t like a panther looking superhero and instead likes the one that shoots webs or looks like a bat, they should and will not like the panther looking one just because there is a black man under the mask.

Acting like we have come so far because of Black Panther’s release is just ignorant to movies with black leads that have come before and to the idea that anybody can be any superhero. Pointing out that black kids should see this because it is a black superhero is making a distinction between races and that is the very thing we are supposed to be avoiding on the path to a society where the color of your skin is completely irrelevant.  


Picture: http://www.btglifestyle.com/blog/2018/02/10/black-panther-spoiler-free-review-video/


4 thoughts on “Race is Where the Line is Crossed with Black Panther

  1. No white person goes to a superhero movie and notices the character is white because historically EVERYONE has looked like them. This concept is really not that hard.

    Who are you as a white person to say that a person of color relates to a white superhero when you don’t even know that?

    Idk why you people act like noticing race is a problem. That’s not an issue, simply because it makes you feel uncomfortable.


    1. Putting “everyone” in all caps is an interesting choice because I can think of a multitude of African American actors that have had great success in their movies as the lead or otherwise. I even name one that happened to be in a superhero movie in the article. Try to read carefully, it’s not really a hard concept. To merely dismiss that is both disrespectful and ignorant to the work those actors put in.

      I am not white, I am a Turkish Iranian mix, but honestly that is outside the point. I specifically name black athletes, as an example, who have built their brand around a white superhero, which shows those athletes do indeed relate to that particular white superhero. Again, read the whole article. It’s not really a difficult concept.

      Noticing race is a wonderful thing because we all have much to learn about the various backgrounds and culture of people all over the world. The problem here is treating race as the dominating reason why a person should or should not like a superhero.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Just because you’re southeast Asian and you feel that seeing a southeast Asian hero on the screen wouldn’t impact in any way doesn’t mean you have the authority to speak on behalf of black people.

    You’re. Not. Black.

    So how could you understand how it feels seeing a movie with an all black cast?


  3. First of all, I am of the belief that no one as the right to speak on behalf of anyone. Even if I was black, one black person saying their opinion does not speak on the behalf of every other black person just because they share a common race. Nobody speaks on the behalf of black people. Each person speaks for themself, to look at someone’s charchteristics or opinions and apply them to a group is called stereotyping, even if they are of the same race. I am giving my opinion based on reason and facts to argue a point. My race has nothing to do with it, whether I was black or not.

    To correct you this was not an all black cast, there were white actors as well, such as Andy Serkis who was one of the main villains. Even if that were the case, I am simply arguing that any child can want to be any super hero, and that race does not play a factor in which comic book character the child happens to like best. The reasons I give for that in the article having nothing to do with race.

    I also make the point that this is not first superhero movie with a black lead, and it is for that reason I don’t see why this movie is the turning point for black actors in Hollywood or in superhero movies. That last point is based on fact, not opinion. Although this was a great movie, when it come to the discussion of race it is not relevant. It was not a major milestone for African Americans in Hollywood due to the success of movies and roles played by African Americans in the past.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s